Neuroscience

Why Time Since Last Cannabis Use Matters in Studies of Young Adults

·

A volunteer responds to a triangle on a screen during a supervised cognitive task.

Two nineteen-year-olds arrive at a university laboratory for a memory test. Both report frequent cannabis use during the past year. One last used yesterday. The other last used two weeks ago. For a survey about annual prevalence, those two answers belong neatly together. For a study of learning and attention, the difference between their calendars may be one of the most informative facts in the room.

A history of use has several clocks

Age at first use describes a point in development. Frequency describes repetition. Time since last use describes the interval before a measurement. A participant can start young, use relatively rarely and happen to use just before testing. Another can start later, use frequently and stop well in advance. Sorting people by only one clock leaves important variation on the other two.

In a systematic review and meta-analysis of adolescents and young adults, researchers found a small overall association between frequent or heavy cannabis use and lower cognitive performance. Among studies requiring more than 72 hours of abstinence, the pooled difference was smaller and did not reach statistical significance. That is a finding about a group of studies. It is easy to turn it, incorrectly, into a personal timetable for recovery.

Why three days is not a biological switch

The studies on the two sides of a cutoff did not put the same participants through identical testing every day. They could differ in recruitment, use histories, verification of abstinence and the tasks selected. Change several features together and it becomes harder to attribute a difference in results to any one of them. A cutoff useful for grouping papers does not establish an instant at which an individual’s performance changes.

There is also a difference between failing to detect an effect and tightly ruling one out. A small subgroup can have an estimate close to zero with considerable uncertainty. A larger study can find a small difference that would be difficult to notice in any one participant. Looking at the estimate and its uncertainty together is more informative than sorting results into significant and nonsignificant piles.

What happened the night before the test?

The recent-use group may include people dealing with residual effects, changes in sleep or symptoms after stopping. The clinical literature on cannabis withdrawal describes sleep difficulties during the days after cessation in some regular users. A tired participant may find a long attention task difficult. Whether altered sleep is part of the effect a researcher wants to measure depends on the question being asked.

If the question concerns day-to-day functioning after someone stops, that tiredness is part of the experience. If the question concerns a lasting developmental change independent of recent sleep, the investigator would want to measure sleep and think carefully about its role. Adjusting for a variable is a scientific choice about what part of the story to include, rather than an automatic improvement to a calculation.

Following the same person

In an abstinence study in adolescents and young adults, gains in verbal learning appeared chiefly during the first week of a month-long observation period. Repeated testing addresses some weaknesses of a one-time comparison. It introduces a new one. People improve on familiar tests through practice. A suitable comparison group and alternative versions of the tasks help distinguish recovery from learning one’s way around the test. A separate two-week study followed changes during monitored abstinence, asking a narrower question than whether young people with different use histories score alike. Studies that follow people from before they first use cannabis, including longitudinal work with twins, can also investigate differences that predate exposure.

Return to the two volunteers. Their scores could match or differ for many reasons. Asking when each last used cannabis will not explain everything, but it determines which explanations deserve serious consideration. The time on the laboratory appointment tells us when the measurement happened. The history leading up to it tells us what kind of measurement we are looking at.